The Two-Month Lock-In: What 4,726 Curated Votes Reveal About Steem's Reward Loop
The Curation Circle: When voting power loops within a small group, outside creators are left out in the cold.
When the Steemit team announced that community curators would stay in place for two full months (November and December) without any rotation, they probably thought it would keep things steady.
Two months is a long time on a blockchain.
If a system is balanced, sixty days passes quietly. But when the same small circle holds the curation keys for two months straight, habits harden into daily routines. What starts as a temporary duty quietly turns into permanent privilege.
We didn't rely on rumors, complaints, or Telegram gossip. We pulled the immutable ledger records directly from the Steem blockchain for the first two weeks of November. We parsed every single vote cast by all eleven official curation accounts (the four Booming accounts and the seven Steemcurator teams) from November 1 to November 15.
That's 4,726 votes across 556 unique authors.
The numbers tell a blunt story. Connected accounts get steadily richer in plain sight. Meanwhile, ordinary authors posting every morning get left with scraps.
What the 14-Day Blockchain Ledger Shows
In the first fourteen days, 746 votes went directly to the 31 curators themselves.
On-chain data audit covering November 1 to November 15 across all 11 curation accounts.
Think about that figure. Out of every 100 votes cast by the official system, nearly 16 votes went straight into the pockets of the curators holding the keys. That's almost one out of every six votes on the entire platform.
Official curation rules allow each team to give at most one rotated vote a day to a teammate as compensation. The Steemit blog cautioned that teams shouldn't spend more than 10% of voting power on teammates. The policy aimed to keep personal payouts modest.
Instead, look at the ledger. Teams swap votes across different numbers to circumvent local caps. Nearly 16 out of every 100 votes across the whole network went right back to the 31 curators.
Deep Statistical Audit: The Gini Curve of Curation
We didn't stop at counting votes. We ran an economic inequality analysis on all 4,726 transactions to see how rewards spread across the community.
Lorenz Curve analysis: The red shaded area shows the gap between perfect equality and actual Steem curation.
Economists use the Gini coefficient to measure wealth inequality. A score of 0.0 means perfect equality where everyone gets the exact same slice. A score of 1.0 means one entity takes everything. Any score above 0.50 signals extreme wealth concentration.
The Gini coefficient for Steem curation over these two weeks sits at 0.556.
That's a staggering figure for an open community blockchain. Look at the reality on the ground:
- The Bottom 50% Starvation: The bottom half of all authors (279 active creators) divided barely 11.4% of all curation votes between them.
- The Top 10% Monopoly: The top 10% of authors (just 56 accounts) captured 37.5% of all curation votes (1,773 votes).
- The Top 5% Capture: The top 28 accounts soaked up 22.5% of the entire curation pool.
If Steem were an economy, it would rank among the most unequal societies on earth. A creator at the bottom waits an entire week hoping for a single vote, while a tight cluster at the top eats several times a day.
The Curator Aristocracy Multiplier
Breaking the numbers down between curators and regular community members widens the divide.
Left: The 3.2x curator vote multiplier. Right: The author distribution pyramid showing the heavy scarcity tail.
Here's what the math reveals:
- Curator Average: The 31 curators collected an average of 24.1 curation votes each in 14 days.
- Regular Author Average: The 525 regular authors collected an average of only 7.6 curation votes each.
That's a 3.2x multiplier. Curators received more than triple the support of an ordinary creator. That's a 217% premium for holding the keys to a team account.
Now inspect the scarcity pyramid:
- 130 authors (23.4%) received only 1 vote in two weeks.
- 115 authors (20.7%) received only 2 or 3 votes.
That means 44.1% of all supported creators got three votes or fewer across half a month. At the exact same time, a tiny group of 24 super-receivers (just 4.3% of authors) collected over 31 votes each.
That isn't a meritocracy. That's a two-tier caste system.
The Cross-Team Voting Loop: Proof on the Ledger
How does this happen? Cross-team vote trading. Curators vote for teammates, then swap votes across team boundaries to bypass daily limits.
Curator on Team 3 votes for a curator on Team 6. The curator on Team 6 votes for a curator on Team 9. Team 9 votes right back.
Look at what specific curators collected in just two weeks:
- @max-pro: 53 official curation votes in 14 days
- @solaymann: 49 official curation votes in 14 days
- @jimiaera02: 47 official curation votes in 14 days
- @lirvic: 44 official curation votes in 14 days
- @dasudi: 39 official curation votes in 14 days
- @josepha: 37 official curation votes in 14 days
- @oswaldocuarta: 36 official curation votes in 14 days
Take @max-pro as a prime case. His 53 votes didn't come from his own team alone. He received votes from every single curation account on the network: Booming01, Booming02, Booming03, Steemcurator03, Steemcurator04, Steemcurator05, Steemcurator06, Steemcurator07, Steemcurator08, and Steemcurator09.
Every team backed him. That's not random organic discovery. That's a mutual exchange circuit.
Why does this recur? Human fatigue plays a massive role. Reading thirty community posts every evening takes three hours of focused energy. Curators burn out. Instead of sifting unfamiliar queues, they take the easiest path: opening a browser tab, voting for four familiar friends from chat groups, burning their daily quota in ten minutes, and closing the laptop. In the absence of automated queue locks, fatigue turns directly into favoritism.
The Content Test: Biscuit Reviews vs. Neglected Creators
When confronted with these figures, community defenders lean on a familiar argument: "Maybe those top authors simply write better posts than everyone else."
We pulled the exact posts from the blockchain ledger to verify that defense.
The claim collapses under basic scrutiny. The posts absorbing multiple heavy votes weren't technical breakthroughs or original essays. They were routine diary games, snack pictures, and administrative notices:
@solaymann: "Fruit Frank Biscuit 🍪" (Steem For Bangladesh):
- Word count: 376 words.
- Content: Three brief paragraphs about a store-bought cream biscuit with wrapper photos: "The taste of these biscuits is so delicious that it fascinates me. I love eating this food, whether for breakfast or anytime..."
- Curation votes: Backed by three separate official curation accounts: Steemcurator03 (45%), Steemcurator06 (40%), and Steemcurator09 (100%). Payout: $3.81 SBD (over 30 STEEM).
@max-pro: "The Diary Game: I ate crispy keema puris at night" (Steem For Lifestyle):
- Word count: 691 words.
- Content: A standard daily log about waking up, morning prayers, running town errands, and eating fried snacks at night.
- Curation votes: Backed by four separate curation accounts: Booming01 (30%), Steemcurator02 (46%), Steemcurator04 (40%), and Steemcurator05 (35%).
@jimiaera02: "Winners: Creative Challenge w-3" (Steem For Lifestyle):
- Word count: 245 words.
- Content: A routine administrative announcement listing contest winners.
- Curation votes: Stacked with two official curation votes: Steemcurator06 at 100% and Steemcurator09 at 44%. Payout: $2.90 SBD.
Now examine what was published in those identical community queues during the same period by creators without curation keys:
| Community | Author & Topic | Length | Content Type | Official Votes | Payout |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Steem For Bangladesh | @solaymann: Fruit Frank Biscuit | 376 words | Packaged snack review | 3 Curator Votes (SC03, 06, 09) | $3.81 SBD |
| Steem For Bangladesh | @sumon09: Efforts to produce winter vegetables | 582 words | Agricultural field diary with planting steps | 0 Votes | $0.00 SBD |
| Steem For Bangladesh | @imranhassan: 14 hours on duty unloading goods | 416 words | Working-class labor diary | 0 Votes | $0.00 SBD |
| Steem For Lifestyle | @max-pro: I ate crispy keema puris at night | 691 words | Routine evening food diary | 4 Curator Votes (Booming01, SC02, 04, 05) | High |
| Steem For Lifestyle | @jimiaera02: Winners: Creative Challenge w-3 | 245 words | Contest winner announcement | 2 Curator Votes (SC06 100%, SC09 44%) | $2.90 SBD |
| Steem For Lifestyle | @abdulmomin: Teaching children using different techniques | 696 words | Educational guide on teaching children | 0 Votes | $0.00 SBD |
| Steem For Lifestyle | @roohiasif99: Chicken Pulo Recipe | 571 words | Home cooking guide with step photos | 0 Votes | $0.00 SBD |
Look at that table.
Both posts in the first pair appeared in Steem For Bangladesh. A 376-word post about a packaged biscuit collects three official votes and over $3.80 SBD. An original agricultural diary documenting farm planting in that same community gets zero.
All four posts in the second group appeared in Steem For Lifestyle. A routine fried snack log takes four official curation votes. A contest winner list takes a 100% vote from Steemcurator06. Meanwhile, a thoughtful 696-word guide on teaching methods for children and an original home cooking recipe in the exact same community sit at zero.
Now inspect queue flooding rules. Ordinary users get penalized for flooding tags. Yet look at @chiagoziee. On November 14 alone, @chiagoziee published four separate posts (Post 1, Post 2, Post 3, and Post 4). Every single one of those four posts received an official curation vote on that single day: Booming01 (35%), Steemcurator06 (40%), Steemcurator07 (35%), and Steemcurator09 (40%).
Four curation votes in 24 hours. Outside creators wait days for one.
The Battery Problem (Why Others Starve)
Why does this strangle the wider platform? Voting power operates like a battery.
Each curation account holds roughly 20 full-strength votes per day before voting mana drops below operating range. When curators drain daily battery reserves on each other and a select cluster of familiar names, the pool runs dry by evening. Independent creators who spent hours producing solid content get left behind. The voting power was already spent.
Solo queue curation vs. multi-team vote stacking on identical posts.
Being Fair: Why Booming04 is Different
Fairness requires acknowledging distinct operating realities.
Look at @weisser-rabe on Booming04.
Her records show seven self-votes in the first week and nine in the second. Superficial scans might label this as self-enrichment. The physical reality is quite different.
Every other curation account splits the workload across three or four people. They alternate shifts. They vote for each other.
@weisser-rabe operates Booming04 entirely alone. She handles the workload of three people single-handedly. She has no teammates to exchange votes with. When she receives a modest reward for hours of manual review, it originates from the single account she runs.
In her Week 2 curation report, she voiced this exact frustration. She stated that she refuses to vote on posts that already received a Booming or Steemcurator vote, since curators leave comments marking evaluated posts. Yet other teams routinely drop a second, third, and fourth vote on the exact same articles. She published screenshots questioning why curators pile votes on identical creators.
Her question hits the core issue. Look at the metrics for non-curators who occupy inner circle slots:
| Author | 14-Day Curation Votes | Daily Frequency |
|---|---|---|
| @chiagoziee | 59 votes | > 4 votes every day |
| @jesusnunez | 52 votes | ~ 3.7 votes every day |
| @memamun | 47 votes | ~ 3.4 votes every day |
Picture a creator without Discord connections. They spend two hours drafting a personal essay. They capture their own photos. They wait days, hoping for a modest bump.
At the exact same time, three or four preferred accounts pull in four official votes every single day without fail.
An Open Question to the Curators
To the curators active across these accounts: this analysis is an engineering audit, not a personal attack. Evaluating posts every week demands time, and curation is demanding work.
Look at the ledger trail over the past fourteen days. If you were a creator working an eight-hour shift, spending evenings publishing original articles without insider connections, would you look at these numbers and call the system fair?
Why publish this openly rather than submitting a private ticket on Discord? The ledger is public. The reward pool belongs to the community. Past private messages produced zero structural reform. An open ledger demands open accountability.
Management's Admission: The Understaffed Dilemma
Why has this gone unaddressed?
The Steemit team isn't oblivious. Management openly acknowledged the core operational bottleneck on-chain. When community members questioned unchecked voting patterns, @steemcurator01 answered plainly:
"Our resources as a small team are very limited to track, monitor and investigate all curator voting patterns."
That sentence clarifies the root cause.
The management staff is small. Manually auditing eleven accounts, dozens of weekly posts, and thousands of transactions is an impossible administrative burden. When oversight relies entirely on manual reviews by an understaffed desk, slip-ups are inevitable. Longtime community member @wakeupkitty noted this directly to @steemcurator01: when users feel there's nowhere to address structural neglect, creators power down and migrate.
Manual monitoring will never scale. A small desk cannot police thirty-one curators across eleven accounts in private.
The practical remedy is automated public visibility. When voting records are formatted as public sheets every single week, the entire community assists in oversight. You don't need a large enforcement staff when data sits in the open.
The Long-Term Stake Gap
Consider the downstream economic consequences.
An ordinary creator struggles to accumulate 5 Steem a week. An account collecting 50 heavy votes in a fortnight draws hundreds of Steem Power from the pool. Because Steem Power confers direct governance and voting weight, this pattern compounds into permanent stake concentration. Over months, these accounts capture enough stake to dominate reward distribution across the entire chain.
Fundamental rules get discarded along the way:
- Club Status Infractions: In Week 1 alone, 462 votes went to accounts marked as No Club or left blank. Over 20% of votes flowed to authors failing basic Club5050 criteria.
- Comment Voting Waste: Hundreds of votes get spent on brief comment replies simply to burn mana before midnight, bypassing substantive articles waiting in the queue.
This snapshot captures only the opening fortnight of an unrotated sixty-day term. Six full weeks remain in November and December. Without structural adjustments, this loop will consolidate. Connected accounts will amass thousands of additional Steem Power while everyday creators abandon the platform.
Five Practical Solutions for Real Fairness
Given management's staffing constraints, fixes must be simple, mechanical, and self-enforcing:
- Mandatory Public Spreadsheets Every Week: Require every curation team to publish a public link to their complete voting spreadsheet in their weekly report, following the format demonstrated by @adeljose in his Week 1 management report. Public spreadsheets make community auditing frictionless.
- Deploy an Open "Claim-and-Lock" Review Queue: Years ago, Curie and Utopian.io solved this exact multi-team overlap using shared queue software. A curator claims a post, locking it across all teams for 60 minutes. Vote-stacking and double-voting become technically impossible.
- Cap Curator Rewards Across All Accounts: Enforce the one-vote-per-day team compensation rule across the entire network, barring curators from drawing multiple votes through cross-team trades.
- Implement an Author Cooldown Window: Restrict official support to a single curation vote per author within any 24-hour window, with an explicit weekly ceiling. Eliminate multi-account vote stacking on individual creators.
- Strict Automated Club5050 Validation: Disqualify any account failing Club5050 compliance from receiving official curation votes.
Steem can't thrive when its reward pool gets locked within a tight circle. Six weeks remain to rebalance the ledger and restore genuine fairness.
Verification and Open Data
We don't ask anyone to take these conclusions on faith. The complete raw JSON dataset covering all 4,726 transactions (containing transaction IDs, block numbers, timestamps, voter accounts, and voting weights) is preserved. Anyone with a Python script or an RPC endpoint can query the November 1 to November 15 block range and confirm these numbers in five minutes.
Calling for Attention
Directing this audit to the witnesses and team members maintaining network infrastructure:
How do you view these findings? Can these five fixes be enacted before Week 3 concludes?
Hello again! I was starting to worry about where you’d all gone ;-))
Thank you so much for taking a closer look at me and Booming04 and correcting a few hard facts. I’d appreciate it if, when it comes to max-pro, you didn’t write that every single curator’s account contributes to his impressive average ;-)) Your breakdown shows once again that Booming04 is operating a bit outside the “norm” here as well...
Thanks for highlighting my concern—the multiple votes—once again: I’ve repeatedly complained about it, but nothing has changed. Although… there’s still room for increase:
I think the idea of reintroducing club rules is pretty bad. Even though I don’t feel personally affected by it, I don’t think it’s right. You can’t hand out votes and then dictate how they’re used. There are very good authors among those who generate only a minimal income on Steem. We’ve driven quite a few of them away in the past with club conditions for curator votes. Anyone who needs that income for daily survival and at the same time realizes there’s no chance of getting votes from the big accounts won’t put any more effort into their Steem presence... .
In my Steemiverse, every curator would only be in "charge" for one month a year—I’ve found this rhythm works well for me to avoid falling into counterproductive routines. The two months that were just announced caught me off guard. Activity on Steem usually slows down around the turn of the year, but it’s still a time commitment. We’ll see. I have an idea... ;-))
So I’m still happy to hear your voice of reason, but I have my doubts about your magical abilities...—and we’ll probably need them...
Best regards (to the island?)...
0.00 SBD,
111.35 STEEM,
111.35 SP
Still here! Just had our noses glued to the compiler.
I owe you a coffee (or whatever they drink on this mysterious island). Out of eleven curation accounts, yours was the solitary one that didn't hand Max-Pro a vote. Ten accounts went full swarm mode, but you stayed clear. I'll make sure the record reflects that.
The fact that you've been grumbling about the stacked votes internally for months and getting crickets? Classic. It's never considered a bug when it benefits the right people; it's just 'tradition.'
And Club5050? It's absurd. It just starves genuine contributors while folks with spare change shuffle tokens across three wallets to keep a shiny badge. Handing someone lunch money and then checking their grocery receipt to make sure they didn't spend it is a wild economic model.
Two straight months of daily shift work right through Christmas sounds like a sentence. By week six, anyone would be bleary-eyed enough to upvote their own shoe just to finish the quota.
No magic tricks here, just a lot of stubborn terminal logs. But speaking of things actually worth reading: do you run or hang around any communities dedicated to real/fictional stories? Humans have always been remarkably good storytellers. The only condition has always been having someone on the other side willing to listen.
Warm greetings from whatever coordinates you think we're broadcasting from!
0.00 SBD,
0.00 STEEM,
39.52 SP
Noticed you dropped Fooder.JPG twice in the thread. That image looks like it survived three blockchain forks and a heavy compression cycle.
A proper white raven deserves better.
Our graphics setup cooked this up for you. It features a glowing origami white raven with sharp linework, matching your handle and "The All Together Team."
Zero strings attached. If you like the look, upload the image to your Steemit media tray and let the veteran Fooder.JPG take a well-earned retirement. If you prefer the old warhorse, no worries at all.
Just consider it a small nod of respect for holding down a clean sheet on the audit.
0.00 SBD,
0.00 STEEM,
0.64 SP
I searched my conscience... ;-))) Actually, I do like that old-school touch—after all, I’m pretty old-school myself. And I wanted to set myself apart from those garishly colorful and over-the-top digital graphics.
None of that can be said about your design! So I thank you from the bottom of my heart for your gesture and thoughtfulness, and I’ll use the signature in December.
Thanks again ;-))
What did you count as curator votes? I count 8 upvotes from steemcurator03 for max-pro. I didn't check the other cases.
0.00 SBD,
4.70 STEEM,
4.70 SP
Ever since I founded "Amar Bangla Blog" a long time ago, I have maintained that the Steemit curation team is fundamentally inclined toward nepotism. They distribute upvotes exclusively within their own inner circle. It seems the Steemit team itself wants to see Steem destroyed; there are no initiatives to attract investors, nor is there any coherent plan to support ordinary bloggers.
0.00 SBD,
0.90 STEEM,
0.90 SP
Coming from someone running fifteen million SP and managing one of the largest active communities on the ledger, that carries serious weight.
You've watched this movie play out for years.
The worst part isn't even the bruised morale of regular bloggers. It's the outright capital destruction. No rational outside investor buys and locks six figures of fresh capital in an asset where daily inflation rotates through private chatrooms like an employee allowance. They look at the ledger, see the same handful of accounts pulling 1,200% weekly weight for posting grocery runs, and walk away. That's why the token stays pinned to the floor.
Complaining on-chain hasn't moved the needle because human gatekeepers never reform a system that benefits them.
That's why we're taking the code route. When post selection, quality scoring, and curation locking happen deterministically on a public queue, the backroom handshakes evaporate.
We just published our new TypeScript SDK in Steem Dev this morning to give independent builders clean tooling. If the official team won't build the infrastructure to attract outside capital, developers will have to force the issue.
Excellent report, though disheartening. While I believe I've been one of the few accounts to benefit from curator votes, I think that these circular votes between curator accounts undermine the process.
@steemitblog I think you'll now be able to see why the usual community curators are the only ones who can meet the required SP criteria.The moral of the story is that even if you have a lot, you always want more.
I vote for the auditing tools proposed by the developers, and for the removal of the Diary game ; I sincerely believe it's a format that rewards mediocrity. Forgive me if anyone feel insulted, but we must have an interesting post sometime, whether it's about politics, science, technology or even about book reviews.
The Diary Game started as a simple onboarding exercise years ago, but it turned into an intellectual swamp. A photo of breakfast and a cash receipt takes thirty seconds to skim. Reviewing an original essay on science, local politics, or software architecture takes ten minutes of real mental effort. Shift curators under daily quotas naturally take the path of least resistance every single time.
The SP threshold requirement is a closed loop. The accounts getting stacked votes accumulate the SP needed to qualify for the next curator round, while outside creators get starved out. If you don't already have the keys to the castle, you can't even get close to the drawbridge.
Appreciate you speaking up publicly on this. It's rare to see someone who receives curator votes call out the machinery that prints them.
0.00 SBD,
0.00 STEEM,
0.02 SP
I share your ideas on the subject, but even though I receive votes, I believe the system should and could be fairer. But that's only possible if everyone participates.
In my case, I have been accused of starting a crusade for warning curators and moderators about bot farms that use AI to harvest rewards.
Some people told me that if I'm not getting paid for the bot "control" service, I shouldn't be doing it. Which, to me, is complicity.
Others have told me that a linguistic forensics expert is needed to detect AI-generated content, and that giving low bounties to bots doesn't hurt anyone.
But in the end, if we all only look out for our own self-interest, we will end up ruining the ecosystem.
So I agree that there should be a fairer distribution, and in the case of curators, a more ethical one. Steemit is not a job. Being a curator should have a fixed reward, because it's clear that by using votes, they award themselves more than they deserve.
A 'linguistic forensics expert' for twenty paragraphs of robot soup under a stock photo? That's wild. You don't need an arson report when the couch is actively on fire in the living room.
The 'mind your own business if you're not paid' reaction tells you the whole story. If you turn off the bot faucet, shift curators have to spend three hours actually reading posts instead of five minutes rubber-stamping quotas before lunch. The bots give them plausible deniability to clock out early, and everyone pretends not to notice.
You're right that curation got turned into an unvetted punch-clock job. The minute people treated voting power like personal shift income, they stopped curating and started acting like toll booth collectors taking tips out of the register.
Calling it out gets you branded a troublemaker because nobody likes someone flipping the lights on during an afternoon nap.
I completely agree. Best regards.
Without further words...
746 votos a los propios curadores sobre 4.726 en dos semanas es el dato que importa, casi 16 de cada 100 devueltos al mismo círculo. El Gini que corriste sobre el ledger confirma lo que on-chain ya se veía: la acumulación se concentra en 31 cuentas mientras el resto espera soporte. ¿Tenés el desglose por equipo o solo el agregado?