Nobody gets paid for a post being good
Nobody gets paid for a post being good. They get paid for standing near it at the right minute.
Take a writer. Call her Tamsin. She is made up. The position she is in is not. Tamsin spends six hours on a piece about why the last bakery in her town closed. She cuts the first draft in half. She rewrites the ending twice. She posts it and watches the page.
A big vote lands before a reader could have reached her second paragraph. The piece takes eleven minutes to read. Whoever voted did not read it. They knew the tag, the hour, the habit of an author who usually does well. Fair enough: maybe the post was going to do well anyway. Tamsin does not feel fair. She feels like the only person in the room who did the reading.
That is the least interesting part of the story. Let the vote go. Ask a different question.
The reader
An hour later a reader arrives and finds the piece good. She pays nothing. She cannot be made to pay, because she could not be kept out. Quality is what economists call a public good: you cannot fence it, and her reading it leaves none the less for the next person. The lighthouse is the usual example. Nobody can bill the ship for the light.
But she leaves with a belief: there are people here worth reading. That belief is the real asset. It keeps newcomers from closing the tab, and it is what makes the token worth holding. Tamsin built it in unpaid, unrecorded hours.
Who pays
So who pays for the lighthouse?
In the plain accounting, Tamsin does. In hours, which are the one currency she cannot print. The reader pays nothing. The holders of the token pay in a thin, abstract way, because the rewards are created from the token itself and spread across everyone who owns it. But they pay without choosing what they are buying. The money is routed by whatever the fastest hands recognise, and the fastest hands are not looking for the lamp. They are looking for the crowd.
So those who gain most from a chain that looks alive fund it by default, and the person who funds it by labour is repaid by accident. If she is repaid at all.
There is no villain here. Public goods have always been paid for by whoever is least able to bill for them. Real lighthouses got built anyway, often funded by dues collected at the harbour and not at the light. Somebody found the place where the beneficiaries could be reached, and put the toll there.
The question under it
On this chain, where is the harbour? Where do those who benefit from the light actually pass through, and what would it take to collect from them for the right reasons?
Until someone answers that, Tamsin learns what everyone learns. By her third piece she spends one hour on the writing and five on the name. Some authors refuse that lesson. They are the reason the reading is still worth anything. They are also the chain's most generous donors, and nobody asked them to be.
So when a post keeps you past its second paragraph, ask a plain question. Who paid for this?