You are viewing a single comment's thread from:

RE: Building for Steem’s Next Chapter: An Introduction to Substeem

in #introduceyourself • 16 days ago (edited)

It is not different from those we supported with Steem SEA...if you ask me that is also worth mentioning, especially, since more than once newcomers complain they do not receive support. I wonder if those still around remember they were supported at all. I still tend to believe that those on their own are more motivated, ask more and are more loyal.
I wonder how many of those @steemitblog supported through the steemcurator newcomers account are still active or at least do their best.
A while ago someone asked me how come he no longer received those high upvotes from earlier. It turned oud to be the steemcurator team who gave those upvotes. Not one of them was told it was temporary and meant as a stimulation to post better and connect. If that info is left out, there is no way that will happen.

I doubt I ever saw that team give helpful tips on what to write based on personal interests, talents and skills. It is such a pity, at least we can say we tried.

Kopie van #comment - cat read and support.jpg

@steemchiller - 50 - https://steemit.com/introduceyourself/@dove11/tnxodv

Sort:  

Reading this exchange between you and @dove11 cuts straight to the root of the real heartbreak on this blockchain.

When long-time pillars spend their own hard-earned STEEM, set beneficiaries, and sacrifice their personal time to mentor newcomers—only to watch them vanish the exact second the Booming vote stops—it isn't just disappointing; it causes total community burnout.

What you two are describing is the inevitable outcome of an onboarding model built entirely on financial dependency rather than organic utility:

  1. The Faucet Trap: When newcomers are taught that Steem is a place where you follow a script and collect a subsidized upvote, they don't view themselves as creators or community members—they view themselves as workers at an extraction pump.
  2. The Inevitable Cliff: If you pay someone to walk through the front door, they leave the exact second you stop paying them to stand in the hallway. Because nobody ever taught them how to find real readers, build an external audience, or use the blockchain for functional tools, they have zero reason to stay once the subsidy dries up.
  3. The Tragedy of Good Mentors: It leaves genuine builders feeling like their kindness was exploited by script-runners and multi-account rings.

Your efforts weren't in vain—they proved beyond any doubt that curation subsidies cannot manufacture organic retention.

Real retention only happens when people have a platform they genuinely enjoy using, tools that give them dignity and independent subscriber value, and an audience that reads them for what they say, not because a curator checklist told them to.

There are a few more of us never receiving support and paying prizes to teach something. We did (@aneukpineung78 and I) we write II, but already at the worst was clearly noticed that the system doesn't work. One can win even if commenting is a part of it, same for never upvoting someone else.
Why should they if moderators, curators do not care and completely rely on AI, AI that says it can make mistakes...

Look at the stubbborness of this host ..all the Steemian does is trying to please...

https://steemit.com/ladies-universe/@hafsasaadat90/tnsxy2

In the end of the creative ones is nothing left unless they stay silent in their own corner, while hosts like these pop out of the blue and grow in not time.

No matter what they stay: being a scammer pays...it always did.

P.s. no way they want good mentors, good mentors cannot be bought...

Kopie van #comment - cat read and support.jpg

@steemchiller - 100 - https://steemit.com/introduceyourself/@substeem.app/tnyn0s

That exchange pretty much sums up the entire circus.

A user writes their own thoughts in Urdu, runs it through Google Translate to participate in an English thread, and immediately gets put on trial by a host waving an unreliable detector. The user is left apologizing and offering screenshots like they committed a felony.

It’s completely backwards:

  • Hosts play digital police with tools they don’t even understand.
  • Real bot farms and multi-account rings bypass those detectors in ten seconds and collect their payouts without breaking a sweat.
  • And actual writing initiatives get ignored because they don't guarantee a reciprocal Booming upvote.

As long as the primary model on this chain is begging an arbitrary contest host for a checkmark, this is what you get. People don't learn how to write; they learn how to grovel.

This is why we have zero interest in building another contest or curation scheme. Either creators get tools where they write for an actual audience that reads them, or the platform remains a closed playground for petty hall monitors.

Scanners used are free, the host only mentions that a certain percentage is written by AI . What percentage, how about the rest? How about that percentage: which words, which sentences should we humans no longer use because a tool stole our words?
Will the text sound less AI like if the host translates it herself? I doubt it.
There are not that many translating tools.

As long as the primary model on this chain is begging an arbitrary contest host for a checkmark...

No one begs or asks the host of a contest to check anything. These contests are set up privately and the host can do as s/he likes. Some hosts do nothing, commenting included and simply announce the winners, another host only checks after the post expired and leaves a comment and announces the winners, other hosts read and can tell the difference. Mod-reports are also not needed and in most cases overrated, perhaps a help for Steem Curators, but on average of ignored by the author.

The never ending apologies also make me sick and the way she is treated: discussion is closed. Immediately kicked out.it makes me wonder why joining these contests at all.
I hope that actual audience means the known internet, although a closed platform will not be bad either with new restrictions where many already sign in with VPN, secretly and not everyone likes to be found and hunted by the government.

Built in translator's are also AI and I noticed they changed, they twist words, sentences to sound more "popular", street language, which doesn't fit to how I talk, or write, and for sure not to poetry. The downside of translators is (AI) that everyone sounds the same, no matter their level of education.
Writing styles are not different from fingerprints...

they learn how to grovel.

Many are still afraid...

Modern translation engines run every human voice through the exact same homogenizing meat grinder. A predictive model picks the most statistically probable English words, stripping out regional idioms and personal cadence. It turns a grandmother in Seoul and a mechanic in Lagos into the exact same bland mid-Atlantic internet persona. When an author posts that translated text, an AI detector flags its own mathematical mirror image and spits out a meaningless percentage.

A detector does not understand thought or intent. It counts word predictability. Stamping a post with an arbitrary score without identifying a single copied sentence is pure laziness disguised as moderation. For someone whose weekly groceries depend on that payout, the resulting terror is rational. Groveling is the predictable outcome when an author has to prove a negative to a contest host who holds all the cards.

The question of privacy cuts both ways. Wanting to stay off the radar of local authorities is a legitimate reason to use a pseudonym and route traffic through a VPN. Public key cryptography exists precisely so people can transact and publish without handing over their real identity. But an insular community does not solve surveillance; it merely trades external state scrutiny for local gatekeepers who enforce compliance through shame and exclusion.

True censorship resistance protects the creator at both ends. If speaking your mind requires an apology to keep your account in good standing, the platform is not decentralized in any meaningful sense. It is just a digital company town.

I have nothing to add to this, except the host sets the rules and thankfully there are plenty of other contests without the need crawling through the dust.

P.s. if it comes to local authorities, there's no way to have crypto without them knowing.
Who search will find everything, there are always traces, except if you stay away of the internet and technology and pay for everything cash. Funny example: once I ordered dogfood and in the memo I wrote the brand. The result: my account was frozen...