You are viewing a single comment's thread from:

RE: Important Update : No more 'robotic comments' from our curators!

in WorldBites • 3 days ago

Greetings, @progressivechef.

Your suggestion is reasonable; however, there is nothing inherently wrong with using template-based comments. Firstly, because we know who cast the vote; and secondly, for the following reason:

Anyone who truly follows the proper procedures for curation work knows that it requires a significant amount of time to read the content, verify its authenticity, check that the user does not have an active "power down" process, and ensure that they have not recently received a vote from the same curation account—not to mention that the platform itself occasionally experiences technical glitches.

Let us remember that those who manage curation accounts are regular members of the community; they also need time to attend to their own activities. I believe it would be perfectly reasonable to ask those in charge to leave specific, personalized comments when necessary—much like SC01 and SC02 do—but not necessarily on every single occasion.

Personally, I believe there are two key areas that require improvement regarding the use of community curation accounts:

  • Avoiding an excessive concentration of votes on a single post.
  • Avoiding support for accounts that show clear signs of "farming."

In my view, genuine comments should be made from one’s personal account; I believe this fosters greater accountability and adds a personal touch, while also serving as a visible form of interaction.

For instance, when analyzing @weisser-rabe strategy, we observe that, according to data published on their blog, their level of interaction fluctuates moderately between 1 and 5 comments per day. In practice, however, they actually post between 10 and 15 comments daily. This discrepancy arises because they make these comments via a curation account; consequently, their actual level of activity is not reflected on their personal blog—a detail that may be significant for each of us.

Regardless of my own personal take, I always support any action that benefits the platform. As they say back home, "The moment someone mentions a carnival, I start tossing confetti." In other words, I am prepared for any action.

Sort:  

Hey @adeljose! Thanks for stopping by my friend.

Happy that this post is bringing in some #genuinecomment , this was the goal of it!Lol!

No, jokes aside, having couple of words from the curators will look very professional same like what @weisser-rabe is putting in place!

And we all know...for her to do this, it takes a lot of real dedication and time.

Or maybe we should look for real 'Curators' - this will definitely solve many problems!

What I mean by real curators :

Steemians who really are here to grow, to have at least 50000 SP , to show signs of powering up, to help others grow, to bring positive energy/vibes at all levels!

And they are rewarded differently, not necessarily by upvotes (maybe they wont have time to post regularly on their own blog)

When having curators who also have to run their own blog + community + contest etc...to earn something, this create many problems...

Let's see if these types of discussions among us do make an effect or not.

But anyway, I am very happy seeing the engagement level rising on different posts these days!

Cheers!
@progressivechef

 3 days ago 

Or maybe we should look for real 'Curators' - this will definitely solve many problems!

We have already established that having a significant amount of SP (Steem Power) is no guarantee that a user will be a good curator.

In my own experience, a good curator must set aside their personal preferences to broaden the scope of their support. For instance, if someone is an art enthusiast, they should not limit themselves solely to that field.

A user managing a curation account can be considered high-quality if they consistently apply the following criteria:

  • Identifying authentic, well-developed written content.
  • Validating authentic, well-captured photographs.
  • Recognizing a content creator’s genuine desire for growth.
  • Avoiding favoritism toward specific content creators when providing support through the curation account.

Each person has their own style, but the dynamic is the same; the difference lies in the amount of time each curator devotes to the task of searching for content on the platform.

Let it be clearly understood: this is my humble point of view.

Yes, you’re absolutely right – my personal activity here is ‘suffering’ because of the time-consuming Booming curation. I noticed the same thing when I took charge of the Dream Steem Community. It’s a shame – but I think it serves a good purpose ;-))

And that's why there must be a mechanism in place, once someone takes the role of curator - auto rewards a bit like for the steem witnesses, or even better, a big amount of delegated sp for the curator, so that the curator grow his/her account with curation generated by that delegation.

I am 100% for having real curators who are here as curators but getting rewarded for doing so.

Then bloggers can do what they do best, that is...blog! Improve in our quality, connect, support and grow.

You are the perfect example the big stake holders should take and invite people of same vision to come forward and show up.

 3 days ago 

And that's why there must be a mechanism in place, once someone takes the role of curator - auto rewards a bit like for the steem witnesses, or even better, a big amount of delegated sp for the curator, so that the curator grow his/her account with curation generated by that delegation.

It seems reasonable to me; however, it is a strategy that would be effective over a period of more than two months—to avoid creating gaps in SP (Steem Power) when delegations are withdrawn—a practice that was applied during the era of Steem representatives.

You are the perfect example the big stake holders should take and invite people of same vision to come forward and show up.

For this observation to be valid, you must add that curators should have the authority to present meaningful criteria in the event that they support the opposite position.

https://steemit.com/steem-pod-team/@weisser-rabe/toliyn

I checked the above and I personally also don't have any problem that users powering down 100-1000 sp, that's fine, they are here to earn too.

Ghosting a user for 100 steem is not clever move from our side, this create bad image for the platform itself. I have some friends (top authors) on the other side (Hive) getting punished and blamed just for powering down for the first time in their 8yrs activity! And I am made aware of that!

We definitely need to keep encouraging everyone how important is powering up.

Curators must have the freedom to reward quality post only...not just for the sake of placing a vote.

When I see hundreds of users powering down million of Steem, then we really look not nice when pushing hard on simple new users who just joined and getting used to web3.

Screenshot 2026-11-17 132507.png

Now if everyone is ok with that, so be it. But I am not among 'everyone' anyway.

 2 days ago 

And the powerdown amount keeps increasing daily : We are at 1,330,000 Steem powered down right now!!!

So, how do you plan to stop this, if we support it?

https://steemit.com/steem-pod-team/@progressivechef/tobt79

  • Some users perform a "power down" to cover service expenses; that is completely acceptable, especially when the price of Steem is so low.

Unlike the users on the list, the individual in this case has made a habit of emptying his wallet continuously over the last few months.

image.png

I mentioned in that comment, it is only the Steemit Top Team giving those generous votes everyday, who need to come up with initiatives to help drop down that power-down amount.

I can only do my little tiny part...thing I have been doing since 2020-2021 and keep motivating my fellow friends to do so also.

We all want the best for Steemit...but many simple things look complicated to start, no idea why!

Sad to see mr aston villa taking out all his sp out though!

Happy to share and discuss ideas like this my friend.
We need more of this...
Best Regards!
@progressivechef

 3 days ago (edited)

"Observe how difficult it is to change yourself, and you will understand how naive it is to try to change someone else".

Voltaire

Avoiding an excessive concentration of votes on a single post.

I don't see an issue with the first point.

Avoiding support for accounts that show clear signs of "farming."

As for this one, I spend less time checking well-known users and look through the entire blog of unfamiliar ones more often. Still, these checks really do take a lot of time.

Sergeyk