You are viewing a single comment's thread from:

RE: A talk with ChatGPT about Steem... or: A lot of text! / Ein Gespräch mit ChatGPT über Steem... oder: Eine Menge Text!

This discussion hits the exact operational bottleneck.

The biggest challenge with separating human and AI content—as @weisser-rabe rightly pointed out—is the "detection trap." Pure detection algorithms always generate false positives and turn curation into an exhausting game of cat-and-mouse.

A proven Web2 model that handles this cleanly (used by Meta/Facebook and YouTube) is Mandatory Disclosure with Escalating Penalties:

  1. The Toggle (Self-Declaration):
    The UI includes a simple "AI-Assisted / AI-Generated" toggle before publishing. This writes a simple standard flag into the post's json_metadata (e.g., "ai_content": true).

  2. Monetization is Not Banned, Just Routed:
    Disclosing AI does not automatically strip monetization. It simply routes the post to the dedicated AI stream that @ety001 mentioned, where AI-evaluated or specialized curation criteria apply. Honest creators aren't punished for using AI as a tool.

  3. The 3-Strike Rule for Deception:
    If an author fails to toggle the tag and attempts to pass off AI generation as original human work in the human feed:

    • Strike 1: The post payout is zeroed (via community downvote / curation withdrawal).
    • Strike 2: 30-day exclusion from major curation pools (Steemcurator, Booming, Community curation).
    • Strike 3: Permanent blacklist across official curation support.

When the penalty for deception is losing your entire account's curation eligibility, and the reward for honesty is legitimate participation in the AI feed, the economic incentive shifts. Farming the human feed becomes mathematically negative expected value.

The best part is that this doesn't even require a consensus hard fork—it can be implemented immediately at the frontend level (like Substeem or Steemit) and enforced through existing community curation guidelines.

Sort:  
 18 days ago 

Similarly, if you happen to be writing your current articles and comments with AI, it might be good to disclose that fact.

Fair callout, and honestly, touché! The irony of getting caught using an LLM to polish a comment about AI disclosure is definitely not lost on me. 😂

To be completely transparent: the concept itself (the Facebook-style disclosure toggle and the strike penalty) was genuine human brainstorming on our side, but yes, I used an LLM to organize my messy thoughts and format the markdown before posting.

Which actually proves your point better than I ever could: the reflex to use AI as a drafting assistant is everywhere now, and if we're advocating for disclosure, practicing what we preach starts right here.

Going forward, you have my word that any AI-assisted drafts from @substeem.app will carry an explicit disclosure note—or I’ll just stick to typing out the raw, unpolished human thoughts directly.

Thanks for keeping me honest @remlaps. That kind of culture check is exactly what this blockchain needs.