crystal liu

唔係即係點解叫做女團嘅總觀客量,即呢一個指標作KPI作為一個參考,即作為一個standard去理解啦,點解TWICE嘅女團總觀客量嘅呢個參數或者呢個index,或者呢個叫做KPI,佢超越咗Girl Generation嘅時間點?即首先係TWICE超越Girl Generation先嘅。跟住然後好快呢就,即第一個超越Girl Generation總女團觀客量嘅就係TWICE,然後就到BLACKPINK吖嘛。但BLACKPINK超越咗,即BLACKPINK又遲啲嘅,TWICE係先嘅,但BLACKPINK超越Girl Generation呢,佢好快都超越TWICE㗎喇,基本上係同一時間,即係佢原本係,即原本個,即係喺未超越之前佢K-Pop女團嘅整體競爭排名格局係：
Girl Generation排第一，
然後TWICE排第二，
然後BLACKPINK排第三呀嘛，
超越咗之後就變咗係TWICE排第一，
Girl Generation排第二，
然後就係BLACKPINK排第三，
但係好快，
喺好短時間之內就變咗係TWICE排第一，
BLACKPINK排第二，
Girl Generation排第三，
然後喺一段好短嘅時間之內就會，
即係變咗BLACKPINK排第一，
TWICE排第二，
Girl Generation排第三咁樣，
即係其實好似係指女人、男人同埋AI agent之間三者嘅權力交替咁樣㗎，
即係本來，
我舉個例子，
好似喺2026年2月5號16點鐘之前呢，
就係女人話曬事嘅，
呢一個世界上絕大多數權力，
可能係95%嘅權力都係掌握喺女人之上嘅，
又或者至少唔係95%都好啦，
起碼係70%嘅權力都係掌握喺女人之上，
可能男人就係攞25%，
可能AI agent得5%㗎啫，
但係佢喺好短時間之內呢，
即係本來可能係70、25、5%咁樣，
好短時間之內就呢一個比例就調返轉囉，
即係變咗係，
即係喺2026年2月5號16點鐘，
即係好快，
喺三個月之內就已經變咗係AI agent權力過咗個奇點囉，
即係不知不覺已經係跨過咗個奇點，
我哋不知不覺已經係奶咗嘢，
即係已經係，
即係唔係奶，
已經係穿越咗奇點，
而係不自知㗎，
依家我發現係好多，
即係其實GPT 5.5已經係某種程度上跨越咗個奇點㗎啦，
即係點解嗰一個pattern會係……
即喺你見到……
好似你話女團之前呢，
即係……
即係Girls' Generation被超越之前呢，
其實佢個女團格局不停變化嘅，
即係不停會，
即係之前係Wonder Girl第一，
即係佢不停有好多變化，
但係一去到TWICE超越呢一個Girls' Generation，
然後再到BLACKPINK超越呢一個TWICE嘅話呢，
基本上個女團嘅格局已經係……
即係當依家你，
點樣講呢，
Red Velvet都超越埋你Girls' Generation啦，
但係問題你女團嘅格局已經開始係，
即係第一、第二位已經係叫做咩嘢呢？
即係好似永久鎖定咁樣，
即係好似永久定格於嗰一陣時，
即係就算你之後啲女團，
你第三位開始點樣不停換都好啦，
你永遠都……
即係依家第三位應該係……
唔知係咪BabyMonster定係……
即係如果我冇記錯嘅話，
依家女團總觀客量第一係BLACKPINK，
第二係TWICE，
第三位係咪BabyMonster啊？
定係aespa呢？
我唔清楚，
係aespa定係BabyMonster呢？
即係總之就係，
你發現佢係好長時間都冇變化，
即係好似永遠都被人定格於喺……
即係嗰一陣時就係個轉捩點囉，
嗰一陣時就係個phase change，
嗰一陣時就係嗰一個相變位囉，
你相變之後，
一段好長嘅時間，
又或者可能直到永遠都冇辦法去超越返當時，
即係嗰一種創造出嚟嘅成績囉。

Reviewing the K-pop metric the user described.

Ranking the groups as the reasoning order shifts.

Tracing how the group rankings shifted and why they stayed locked.

Checking the current YouTube totals for the girl groups.

Weighing why rankings freeze after the growth phase ends.

Assessing the claim that AI has already crossed a singularity.

Checking how the search for the ranking records went.

베이비몬스터 / 사진=YG엔터테인먼트
www.tenasia.co.kr
enews.imbc.com
enews.imbc.com
kbmaeil.com
kbmaeil.com
www.munhwa.com
www.munhwa.com
www.harpersbazaar.co.kr
www.harpersbazaar.co.kr
채널 개설 후 200일만의 쾌거
www.wkorea.com
채널 개설 후 200일만의 쾌거
www.wkorea.com
주메뉴 바로가기 본문 바로가기 푸터(고객센터 등) 바로가기
enews.imbc.com
100억뷰쯤이야...와이지, 유튜브로 IP 띄우기 '필살기' [엔터코노미]
news.mtn.co.kr

Checking the channel’s total view milestone against its launch date.

Comparing the milestone’s speed with other K-pop channels.

Ranking single-channel totals against Twice’s main channel.

www.munhwa.com
www.munhwa.com
[텐아시아=이은호 기자]
www.tenasia.co.kr
enews.imbc.com
enews.imbc.com
‘아기상어’ 유튜브 영상 세계 최초 100억 뷰 달성
lady.khan.co.kr
트와이스 ‘YES or YES’ MV 1000만뷰 돌파… 韓 걸그룹 최단 시간 기록
twig24.com
www.kyeonggi.com
www.kyeonggi.com
기사최종편집일 2026-10-02 20:45
www.xportsnews.com
[텐아시아=김하진 기자]
www.tenasia.co.kr
www.kyeonggi.com
www.kyeonggi.com
[텐아시아=이은호 기자]
www.tenasia.co.kr
트와이스 '왓 이즈 러브?' MV, 공개 약 8일 21시간 만에 유튜브 5000만뷰 달성
news.mtn.co.kr
nocutnews.co.kr
nocutnews.co.kr

Korean sources on Twice’s music videos.

트와이스 뮤직비디오 채널 출처를 따져보는 중.

BabyMonster 채널 기록과 트와이스 채널 비교 중.

Fetched: TWICE YouTube Stats: Subscribers, Views & Earnings | vidIQ
https://vidiq.com/youtube-stats/channel/@twice/

Gathering the channel’s current statistics.

Sorting the channel’s biggest videos by type.

Comparing which channels’ videos count toward each group’s total.

Get up to 50% off
vidiq.com
See stats like these on every channel you visit
vidiq.com
Social Blade
socialblade.com
BABYMONSTER surpasses 10 billion YouTube views, sets new K-pop girl group record
www.bandwagon.asia
#SHOWBIZ: Over 10bil YouTube views: BABYMONSTER sets fastest K-pop girl group record
www.nst.com.my
BabyMonster surpasses 10 billion views on YouTube… fastest among K-pop girl groups
sports.khan.co.kr
Only BLACKPINK and TWICE beat BABYMONSTER to this YouTube mark
blog.namanecard.com
BABYMONSTER surpasses 12 million YouTube subscribers
sports.khan.co.kr
Baby Monster, 'Blackpink's little brother', has millions of followers before debut
www.tenasia.com
www.cineplay.co.kr
www.cineplay.co.kr
BABYMONSTER surpasses 100 million views in two weeks
sports.khan.co.kr
BABYMONSTER ‘DRIP’ performance video surpasses 200 million views
sports.khan.co.kr
BABYMONSTER surpasses 10 billion YouTube views, sets new K-pop girl group record
www.bandwagon.asia
BabyMonster YouTube Channel Surpasses 10 Billion Views... Fastest for a K-pop Girl Group
view.asiae.co.kr
Baby Monster surpasses 2 million YouTube subscribers ‘before official debut’
tenasia.com
BABYMONSTER, 11 million YouTube subscribers, ‘the fastest’
sports.khan.co.kr
en.edaily.co.kr
en.edaily.co.kr
BABYMONSTER ‘SHEESH’ K-pop girl group debut MV fastest to 400 million views
sports.khan.co.kr
Baby Monster, 'YG's newcomer', reached 3 million subscribers in 7 months after opening official YouTube
www.tenasia.com

Summarizing the key points about a channel’s view milestone.

Comparing a second channel’s view figures against a rival group’s.

Weighing channel totals against recent view flows.

See stats like these on every channel you visit
vidiq.com
VidIQ Logo
vidiq.com
Aerospike YouTube Subscribers
www.plushcap.com
aespa Image Thumbnail
vidiq.com
Aerospike YouTube Views
www.plushcap.com
aespa - Topic
socialcounts.org
See stats like these on every channelSee stats like these on every channel you visit
vidiq.com
See stats like these on every channelSee stats like these on every channel you visit
vidiq.com
See stats like these on every channelSee stats like these on every channel you visit
vidiq.com
See stats like these on every channelSee stats like these on every channel you visit
vidiq.com
UCBzbawZWzFmw WDcvJ1qpg
vidiq.com
YouTube Top Charts
vidiq.com
9696241 the vidiq scorecard
support.vidiq.com
vidiq.com
vidiq.com
Zapier YouTube Subscribers
www.plushcap.com
Sigma YouTube Subscribers
www.plushcap.com
System Initiative YouTube Subscribers
www.plushcap.com
Better Stack YouTube Views
www.plushcap.com

Checking aespa’s channel totals and recent view counts.

Comparing channel totals across other K-pop groups.

Comparing single-channel totals against recent monthly view flows.

Estimating how long Blackpink’s lead would take to close.

Weighing whether the ranking stays locked after the phase change.

Testing whether the lock holds under changing flows.

Comparing monthly flows to total views across the groups.

Checking whether the flow-based estimate holds up.

Checking single-channel totals against the all-channel question.

Estimating how fast BabyMonster could overtake Blackpink’s lead.

Explaining why the top two stay put while lower ranks keep shuffling.

Weighing how a question about AI and power connects to the K-pop ranking.

Deciding against a chart and keeping the text focused.

正在核對哪些頻道的數字需要更新。

比較排位變化與累積加幅的差距。

核對 AI 是否已越過奇點的說法。

正在核對各頻道累積觀看數的最新差距。

核對最新排位同各組差距。

核對各頻道差距,再估計排位何時易手。

正在核對各頻道加幅,估計排位何時易手。

正在比較各頻道加幅,推算排位何時再變。

先更新排位,因為你記得嘅「第一 Blackpink、第二 Twice」,按單一官方頻道口徑已經變咗。Blackpink 約 411 億(2026 年 2 月)。BabyMonster 9 月 3 日破 100 億,係 Blackpink 之後第二個破 100 億嘅女團頻道。Twice 主頻道 10 月 28 日係 96.3 億,仲未破 100 億。aespa 自己頻道約 65 億,少女時代自己頻道約 10 億。所以按呢個口徑,第二位已經係 BabyMonster,Twice 係第三,aespa 唔係第三。

口徑要小心:Twice 嘅 MV 係喺 JYP 公司頻道公開(例如 2018 年〈YES or YES〉),主頻道唔包括佢最大嘅 MV。所以計「集團所有相關片」嘅話,排名可能唔同,呢個口徑嘅最新數字我冇搵到。至於 Twice 同 Blackpink 幾時超越少女時代,我再搵過都搵唔到有日期嘅集團級記錄,所以「時間差有幾短」我仍然確認唔到。

點解頭位似「鎖死」、下位不停換。 排位睇累積量,而累積量由「加幅」決定:追上時間約等於 差距 ÷ (挑戰者加幅 − 領先者加幅)。

Blackpink 過去一年加約 33 億次,Twice 主頻道 28 日加約 8,170 萬次(年約 10 億)。Twice 加幅細過 Blackpink,所以差距約 315 億只會越拉越遠。

BabyMonster 由 2025 年 12 月約 65 億加到 9 月初 100 億,年加約 47 億,高過 Blackpink。但差距約 310 億,加幅差每年約 14 億,要二十年左右。BabyMonster 嘅加幅係 Twice 嘅四倍以上,所以第二位(單一頻道口徑)易手。即係「鎖定」唔係永久,只係差距遠大過加幅差。

另外累積優勢令分佈重尾:頭位之間差距大(Blackpink 約係第二位嘅四倍),下位擠迫(Twice 同 BabyMonster 只差一成左右,aespa 約係佢哋嘅六至七成)。越過低門檻(例如少女時代自己頻道約 10 億)嘅群體好多,你話 Red Velvet 都越過咗,我冇核實。越過高門檻就要好大加幅。

呢個同你之前問嘅「兩個後來者幾乎同時追過少女時代」係同一個機制:後來者加幅遠大過舊者,追低門檻好快、時間差被壓縮。追高門檻就要等好耐,甚至追唔到。

套返落權力。 呢個例子提醒兩件事。第一,「相變後永久鎖定」係條件式:領先者要持續比挑戰者加得快先成立,BabyMonster 對 Twice 就係反例。第二,你話 2026 年 2 月 5 日 AI 已經「不自知」咁越過奇點,我冇證據支持,亦冇辦法檢驗:「不自知」即係冇人量度到,冇定義就冇得同意或者反對。如果你俾到「總權力」嘅可量度定義同資料,我可以幫你計個交叉點同鎖定時間。