POLL: Which Post/Comment, of someone else, Deserves an Upvote? Why?

in CCC15 days ago

Oh, how you’d love to get that massive upvote, but no matter what you do, it always passes you by.




20260831_132042.jpg


And then you look at the Steemit feed on the homepage and see the most ridiculous posts that have received high votes, or so it seems, at least, and yes, here too, appearances can be deceiving.

It’s not usually the Steem Curator accounts or the Booming Vote accounts that are active here.
Both types of account are, by the way, a brilliant initiative, with an army of people having worked on them for a few years now to provide other users of this platform with votes. As I wrote earlier, in some cases such a vote is a payment, whilst in more it’s given as motivation to do better or as an incentive to be more active. It’s only very rarely that a post gets an upvote because it’s so brilliant – including the title, image and hashtags.

Of course, improving and being more active won’t happen if there are no guidelines or if no comments are left suggesting what could be improved. Personally, I sincerely hope that we do not return to the situation prior to 2025, where moderators – who were themselves far from being good writers – began dictating the rules to others under the guise of ‘this is what the Steemit team says’. If, at the time, I entered into a discussion with such a moderator and asked them to provide evidence of this, no evidence could be produced and the matter was simply brushed aside.

Now, as participants on the platform, we are on the verge of embarking on a new path, one that isn’t actually new at all. Writing standards must improve; progress must be made in the use of titles, hashtags and the content of posts; and, in fact, the same applies to the comments.

The whole platform is built on maintaining connections and helping each other grow, so that includes giving upvotes; not just taking!

You can only build a strong platform with all its members, and you can only build a strong community when everyone does their bit. Expecting to receive because you ‘work’ whilst you’re not prepared to give anything to others is a situation that, in my view, has gone on for far too long.

When it comes to a ‘booming vote’s, it isn’t all that different from a Steemcurator account vote. The ‘booming’ accounts may be able to give a higher vote, but there’s no guarantee that they’ll actually receive 100 per cent. It may well be that you earn more with several lower votes than with a single booming.

Are you artistic, a painter or sculptor, or perhaps a photographer? Do you have a talent, or are you a creative writer who lets fictional stories or poems flow from your pen without the help of AI? Then your work can make Steemit far more appealing, especially if you invest some time in raising your profile and maintaining contacts.

Which post or comment of someone else do you think deserves an upvote?

I’m talking about a post or comment, not the person!
What’s the reason? And no, ‘hard work’ or spending days on a post doesn’t count as a reason. The end result does, because that’s what ultimately gets seen or goes unseen. Why did you decide to read that post from start to finish? Did you vote on this post yourself and left a comment?

Leave the link in the comment section and tell why this post is, according to you, that special that it deserves an upvote! And no, this is not about you, your post, your talent but being able to find those who benefits Steemit.








2-9-2026


(html comment removed: steemx:poll)


📊 POLL: Which Post/Comment, of someone else, Deserves an Upvote? Why?

  • Well written, entertaining
  • Very good, fitting to the post, photos
  • A long, personal comment
  • Comment + continuing talking
  • Catching title
  • Funny
  • True art
  • The weirdest post ever
  • Touching
  • Other... Please, explain

Poll — pick up to 3 · voting closes Wed, 09 Sep 2026 07:30:00 GMT. Vote on SteemX.

(html comment removed: /steemx:poll)

Sort:  
 14 days ago (edited)

How does this poll work @wakeupkitty? I think I missed the voting.

I usually go for posts/comments that speaks from the heart, not sure how but when I read, I can feel what is written and I like it when the person takes pride in what they write - the content, the format, photos, creativity in writing, etc. And it is nice to see the effort some take to create, beautify their posts. And especially so when they take the time and effort to explain step by step. Not easy to do, especially with photos and such. I'm not saying it has to be fancy but I think we can see it. I don't like it when the posts look / 'read' rushed.

I like simple, straightforward titles - not long, complicated and confusing ones. I like catchy titles too. Some posts, I don't understand and therefore am not able to comment, even after I read two or three times.

Some posts (or comments), seems like they are "trying too hard" or taking advantage? Sometimes I am not able to "see" the true identity at first but realised it later. I realised there were many like this when I hosted and moderated the 2 communities back then, that I grew tired, confused and disappointed. I think that was why I left. Especially with the split, it became too political or toxic back then.

I will explore and share a sample post that I think deserves a good upvote later. I found one earlier... Be right back :)

 14 days ago (edited)

I enjoyed this one @wakeupkitty, what do you think?
https://steemit.com/moments-in-focus/@marcoteixeira/a-bookshop-without-a-door-or-hay-on-wye

I liked that @marcoteixeira explained his thought process with the structured sections from start till the end. Although it is just 1 photo (which is inline with his "Moment of Focus"), he took the time to share his thoughts and ended it with a technical Photo Notes that gave meaning to his photo. And it is not merely plopping a photo and a few sentence. And there is a unique sense of creativity in the way @marcoteixeira wrote which I enjoyed reading.

Thank you so much for your kind words and for taking the time to read my post so carefully. I’m really glad you enjoyed not only the photo, but also the thoughts and story behind it. Your feedback means a lot and encourages me to keep sharing these little moments through my photography. 😊📷

 11 days ago 

Yes yes, please share more. I do agree with @wakeupkitty that adding more photos will enhance your post even more though I respect that maybe your single photo is to keep inline with your title or theme?

Will you read and comment on her too?

This BOOMING vote is yours and well deserved!
❤️🍀

TC11-WUK-Boom-sept26.jpg

 14 days ago 

I know him. It is good to see he took the time to add a bit more info and his personal note (no wikipedia).

Thank you for sharing this link and explaining why you liked it.
If it came to me I would have liked to see a few more pictures since this one could have been taken everywhere in Europe.

This booming vote is yours and well deserved.
❤️🍀

TC11-WUK-Boom-sept26.jpg

 12 days ago 

Thank you thank you! 💕

 14 days ago 

You can only see the poll and click ✅ on some of the answers if you log in to SteemX. Most people can’t do that, and many aren’t willing to sign up for everything.
I was asked to try out the poll, but I think I’m now the only one using it. No problem – there are plenty of questions to ask, and it’s a way to keep in touch, share experiences or just have a chat.
It’s a bit like Monkey Business, which I used to run – asking questions about Steemit.

Until about 1 to 1.5 years ago, the atmosphere there was still toxic, and I tried hard to bring about changes – for example, regarding the issues with moderators, club status and more.
What has helped enormously, by the way, is that I’ve stayed within my own bubble (community). I’m mainly here to write, make connections and not to argue. That doesn’t mean I condone corruption, scams or spam, but I’ve given up on trying to change the world on my own if I always have to fight and others end up taking the credit, whilst I get stabbed in the back and they stand on the sidelines watching.

I love my peace and quiet, and I love writing, painting and things like that. It’s not as if I’m bored stiff and find it a pleasure or a massive thrill to fight a battle I know I’ll lose from the start. I’ve also been away for a while. There’s life outside Steemit, and that’s a good thing. I’d really feel sorry for myself if this were the only thing in my life.
The point is that Steemit gives me energy rather than draining me and causing stress. If that were the case, I’d stop. I understand exactly what you mean.

This booming vote is yours and well deserved.
❤️🍀

TC11-WUK-Boom-sept26.jpg

 12 days ago 

Thank youuu 💕

 15 days ago (edited)

I'll share this link from a creative writing post. I love the way this user built a deep story by linking four different paintings. It has already being upvoted by a curator team.
https://steemit.com/@casv/entre-la-tierra-y-el

I think this post fits: >Well written, entertaining / Very good, fitting to the post /Catching title/Touching.

I upvoted it myself and left a more less concise comment in which I explain what I like and what I thought.


I'll add something else regarding comments and upvotes.
The comments I leave can be short or long (it depends). Sometimes I don't feel inclined to leave a comment, but I usually upvote any post I pay a visit to. Sometimes I also resteem.

If I don't like what I have read/seen, you won't notice since I leave silently, without upvoting or commenting.
I usually won't comment on users I know won't reply (not sure if they read the comments).

And also must admit sometimes I upvote posts not so well written to support the users and finally it's not that I like to tell someone "you could improve orthography, grammar or the use of signs", so I don't do it because anyone could read it and the autor feel bad.
I'm flexible about some mark down, for exemple justifying text or adding caption to all images.

Wow! Muchas gracias por tu referencia y apoyo, es muy amable y sincera.

Feliz y bendecido día para tí..!

 14 days ago 

I wonder how you figured that out so fast ...

Y usted muy talentoso, amigo. Se merece el apoyo.
Amén. Bendiciones.

 14 days ago 

If it comes to the post/author I agree.
If it comes to double opvotes if you ask me it is not forbidden, it does happen the only issue is that only one can nominate the post.

With you I also uovote to support, but I tell what could be improved if I do believe this Steemian can make it. If not I leave, say nothing since I learned 90% doesn't care, not even if they complain they are willing to edit or remember/write down some little tricks. I gave up on pulling at dead horses.

Thanks for taking the time to write a great comment and leave an excellent link.

🍀❤️

Thanks to you for giving the chance to set an opinion about someone else's content.
Well, it seems we have learn. Some users get the support anyway, altought don't improve posts, so maybe don't care.

Anyone should wish to improve since our posts show a part of who we are and we all should also care about leaving a good impression of and on Steemit.

 13 days ago 

No me parecen que las reacciones sean muy entusiastas, pero la verdad es que tampoco lo esperaba, sobre todo al compartir un enlace de otra persona. ¿Quizás se vea como una amenaza? Por mi parte, me pregunto más bien por qué a los demás les gusta algo o, por el contrario, no les gusta. Acabo de hacer de moderador en Steem for Betterlife, porque esa comunidad ya está empezando a llenarse de basura, igual que Dream Steem. Los curadores, que deberían ayudar a dar visibilidad a la gente y animarla a ser más creativa y a escribir algo diferente —lo cual a menudo se consigue con cambios muy pequeños, como un título distinto, mejorar primero la foto u otros hashtags—, parecen recurrir todos a reglas muy antiguas, como un mínimo de palabras y una fecha en el título porque se trata de un diario, un «trius», etcétera, etcétera, y con ello se echa por tierra toda la creatividad. Esto me entristece y no creo que esta prueba vaya a funcionar. Ya me estoy encontrando con un comportamiento muy autoritario, igual que el de muchos moderadores de hace dos años. No creo que los moderadores y curadores que llevan más tiempo sean muy flexibles ni sean capaces de dar vida a la plataforma.

I don’t find the reactions overwhelming yet, but to be honest I didn’t really expect them to be, given that I was just sharing someone else’s link. Perhaps this is seen as a threat? Personally, I’m more interested in why others like something or, conversely, why they don’t. I’ve just been acting as a moderator on Steem for Betterlife, as that community is already starting to get rather cluttered, just like Dream Steem. The curators, who are supposed to help make people more visible and encourage them to be more creative and write something different – which can often be achieved with very minor changes, such as a different title, a better photo or different hashtags – all seem to be reverting to very old rules, such as a minimum word count and a date in the title because it’s a diary or a trius, and so on and so forth. And so, once again, all creativity is being stifled. It saddens me, and I don’t believe this experiment will work. I’m already encountering very authoritarian behaviour, just like that of a large number of moderators from two years ago. I don’t believe that the moderators and curators who have been there for some time are very flexible or capable of bringing the platform to life.

help make people more visible and encourage them to be more creative and write something different

This is key. I think that when we talk about "improvement," it depends on what we consider "improvement." For some, it means following a set of rigid "rules" and parameters, such as word count, text justification, a certain number of images, and even repetitive captions. This is a flawed approach. I think, for example, that content can be excellent with fewer than 300 words, an original image, and a good title. It all comes down to the filter of criteria and flexibility. A post isn't good simply because it has 300 words and is justified. Unfortunately, many moderators, who are also curators, focus on these aspects, which doesn't necessarily make anyone more visible or creative. Currently, with the incentive of comments for improvement through votes, I fear that some recommendations will be made simply for the sake of making them, or that they won't actually impact quality or creativity because the approach is more prescriptive.


Esto es clave. Pienso que cuando se habla de "mejorar" depende de lo que consideremos es eso. Para algunos será seguir una cantidad de "reglas" y parámetros cerrados, como número de palabras, justificación del texto, cierta cantidad de imágenes, captions aunque sean repetitivos. Es un error de criterio.

Yo pienso por ejemplo que un contenido puede ser excelente con menos de 300 palabras, una imagen propia y un buen título. Todo pasa por el filtro de criterios y flexibilidad.

Un post no es bueno solo por tener 300 palabras y estar justificado, lamentablemente muchos moderadores que también suelen ser curadores se centran en esos aspectos, lo cual no necesariamente va a hacer más visible y creativo a nadie.

En estos momentos que están motivando con votos el hacer comentarios para mejorar, me temo que habrá recomendaciones que se haga por hacerlas o que realmente no tengan un impacto en la calidad o la creatividad porque el enfoque es más bien normativo.

 13 days ago 

I don’t really believe in change anymore. The problem is that the curators – or those whose job it is to guide others – need to be helpful, offering tips and advice that actually work, and this used to apply to those welcoming newcomers as well. When they aren’t on the same page, don’t share the same opinion and – as @thegorilla pointed out at the time – literally need to have every single step spoon-fed to them, and even when everything is spelled out on paper, it still isn’t read or is misunderstood, then there’s nothing to be done. This probably also means that only people who can read with understanding – and perhaps don’t need to translate anything – can take on this task, as well as those who haven’t made a name for themselves by carrying out all sorts of tasks for the Steemit Team.

What bothers me most of all is that community rules are being ignored by the improvers, who simply penalise people for taking part in creative competitions and following the rules.

It’s sad, but without creative curators who are open-minded and flexible – and not too business-minded to realise that the old method doesn’t work – this platform won’t last long, at least not with a Steem that still has any value.

Perhaps that’s the only upside. The greedy ones will disappear, and the rest will stay until the last server pulls the plug.

Ya no creo tanto en un cambio. El problema es que los curadores, o quienes deben guiar a los demás, deben ser serviciales, dar consejos y recomendaciones que realmente funcionen, y esto también se aplicaba antes a quienes daban la bienvenida a los recién llegados. Cuando estos no están en sintonía, no comparten la misma opinión y, como ya señaló @thegorilla en su momento, necesitan que se les explique literalmente cada paso, e incluso si todo está detallado por escrito, si esto no se lee o se malinterpreta, entonces no hay nada que hacer. Esto probablemente también significa que solo las personas que pueden leer con comprensión y tal vez tampoco necesiten traducir nada pueden asumir esta tarea, además de aquellas que no han llegado a donde están por realizar todo tipo de tareas para el equipo de Steemit.

Lo que más me molesta es que los improvers ignoran las reglas de las comunidades y simplemente sancionan a las personas cuando participan en concursos creativos y siguen las reglas.

Es triste, pero sin curadores creativos que sean abiertos y flexibles, y que no sean lo suficientemente pragmáticos como para comprender que el método antiguo no funciona, esta plataforma no tendrá una vida larga, al menos no con un Steem que aún tenga algún valor.

Quizás esa sea la única ventaja. Los codiciosos desaparecerán y el resto se quedará hasta que el último servidor se apague.

This booming vote is yours and well deserved.
❤️🍀

TC11-WUK-Boom-sept26.jpg

Thank you!

This is difficult to answer because it is not possible to read every post and comments on steem. I, being a busy man, don't find time to read a lot here. Honestly, not many read posts and comments here. So, it is not possible for me to answer. But, this doesn't mean that this platform is devoid of good posts and comments. Lots of people are working hard and creating superb posts.
I appreciate people like you who encourage people to post good content. Have a nice day!

 11 days ago 

A great day to you and start of the week.
I appreciate your honest answer which is always better than making up something or pretending to read and comment.
I am happy you find time to join and bring us some joy.

❤️🍀

 8 days ago 

O nasty is the waste policy my deer friend. So, I am always practicing it. But, I need a little perfection for this.

 5 days ago 

Thanks a lot.

When I first came to Steemit, I learned from friends that you can write a lot of things here according to your wishes and they are evaluated. I was quite happy and shared my writing here, but various communities did not take my story writing well, due to which I stopped sharing stories on this platform. However, I did not give up writing stories, but it will be about a week since I came to know about this community through the steem official team and joined this community. And I think that the post that does not have any artificiality, there is no force in saying that there is no artificiality, the post that is shared from the heart and the comment that gives good guidance to the poster and encourages his work is a good comment

 13 days ago 

Here in this Community, we’re all about creativity and supporting one another. Supporting one another often falls short, because it involves not just reading and leaving a comment, but also giving each other an upvote – but we’ll keep trying. Creativity knows no bounds and often no rules either, which is why this Community doesn’t have many either. We don’t use the ‘report to moderator’ function; we simply choose whether or not to leave a message. It should remain a relaxed experience for everyone, as reading through posts and writing comments takes up a huge amount of time. I believe we have a lovely Community here, and many of us also post in a few others where things aren’t taken too seriously either. The only thing we don’t accept here is participation in the recent ‘thediarygame’ project. This is because the entries always have boring titles and often just list the things done in a day. Besides, after all these years, there hasn’t been much improvement in many people’s writing style.
You’re also welcome to take part in competitions if you feel like it, but of course you don’t have to. Focusing on your own niche – in your case, stories – is always best.

Personally, I sincerely hope that we do not return to the situation prior to 2025, where moderators – who were themselves far from being good writers – began dictating the rules to others under the guise of ‘this is what the Steemit team says’. If, at the time, I entered into a discussion with such a moderator and asked them to provide evidence of this, no evidence could be produced and the matter was simply brushed aside.

You called them out in a way which I think it's good.

In each of the categories you have mentioned above, I think it would depend on each individual's perspective. But, I think when someone is sharing their opinion (or, as you have mentioned: personal comment). I would go with the below as a good example:

https://www.steemit.com/dream-steem/@wakeupkitty/tklxbn

 15 days ago 

This is a poll asking for the participant’s – in this case, your – personal opinion or thoughts and in the case your opinion of it comes to good comments.

A survey is pointless if everyone simply fills it in based on what they think might be the reason someone else is responding in a particular way.

Thanks for the link, which is mine. Meaning it is not of any help. Is there someone else you can recommend?

You’ve only said that you would respond in that way. Did you ever write such comments, be straight and shared your thoughts?

Please, explained why,this is a good example. I'm still waiting for an answer + link. See if you can find one.
Thank you.

Alright, thanks. To a certain point, I do. But, not in all the comments. Some of them are just short. I will share with you, if I find any comment as such.

 14 days ago 

Great! I look forward to see such a comment, one appealing enough to you to reply.

By the way: a longer talk with shorter comments/replies also makes a good example. What counts is the connection (built) and sharing info, tips, showing interest.

I hope you are fine. Still struggling with a writer's block? Ever tried to draw or paint?

A good weekend.
🍀❤️

When we feel like someone is like us, we want to notice their every move and we find ourselves in them. After reading this post, I felt as if it was written for me, even though they have told about their own selves. I am sharing this link with you so that you too can realize that a person cannot do anything by being idle. Therefore, it is better to keep yourself busy and show yourself by doing something better. I think this post is the best for voting.

https://steemit.com/animals/@lupega/this-is-the-life-i-deserve-i-d-better-go-to-work

 14 days ago (edited)

What exactly do you mean? That you’re just like that dog? Or that you’re useless? Or that you’re a hard worker?
I find these short messages hard to understand; I don’t see any response from you either, no attempt to make contact or start a conversation about what exactly made you feel that you’re the same.
And why do you want to know everything about him? What’s the reason, and if that’s the case, why don’t you leave a comment?

Personally, I don’t find this a particularly appealing post; perhaps it’s more like a meme. I suppose it’s meant to be funny, but that message doesn’t come across to me. Perhaps it’s down to the translation, or perhaps I simply don’t get it.
I reckon you do have a sense of humour, as I often gather from your comments.

As a curator I wouldn't upvote posts like these. It misses something and it doesn't look as if the text is taken well care of. Also the standard line underneath attracts too much attention, it is disturbing.
It is also not #creativewriting but posted in a hurry.

Thank you for taking part.

cc @lupega you can do so much better, but it seems it is just occasionally. It will limit your growth since like these is what one mostly see.

 14 days ago 

hahaha,It's just a sleeping dog. He looks happy; look at his expression while he sleeps. He's probably having a nice dream. I don't think he's dreaming about anything work-related.
https://steemit.moecki.online/animals/@lupega/this-is-the-life-i-deserve-i-d-better-go-to-work

 13 days ago 

Food!

20260902_163429.jpg

The last question you mentioned matches my personality. I am a very hardworking lady and I don't like wasting time at all. Even if I am resting on the bed after finishing all my work, I am still taking online classes on my mobile.
I also saw the aspect of hard work in this post, so I found myself similar to it.

 14 days ago 

You sound like me and are also your own biggest slave driver.
It is not resting if you study dear friend. Take good care of yourself l, do not forget to relax.

I am not too sure, but if you ask me the remark about hard working was sarcasm since the dog mainly sleeps.

This meant that I didn't get to the bottom of the matter.

 13 days ago 

We can dive in and ask what I meant 🤔

In your opinion, the link to the post I shared is not appropriate for voting because in it I described myself according to this post, while you said that in fact a dog sleeps all day, while I presented myself as a hard worker.

 12 days ago (edited)

Your comment I find good but the post no. Not because you misunderstood or I did or I have no sense of humour but because I do not see much effort put in it and it doesn't look like a post taking care of.

I like to vote for what is creative, artistic and I also need to explain why I voted for this, if I intend to nominate this. I cannot with this quick post. Also @lupega can do way better and the difference is too big. If I vote for him and nominate him SC01 or 02 should see similar posts or comments and not a huge difference about what is posted.

Feel free to come up with a different link.